What are your top 3 Eddie’s?

[Peppoah]

I can’t decide which one I like best. But I know which one I don’t like and I think he has the worst design: for me it’s Hallowed Eddie.
Hallowed be thy name is my alltime favorite Maiden Song, but his design doesn’t do the song any pride.
I know that he’s designed after the trooper Beer. His design could need to be reworked. That’s my opinion.

[Icarus]

For me
1- Navigator (almost for everything)
2- Rainmaker (Arena)
3- Viking (Arena alternative and works with everything)

Anyways, i never had an Aces High and i want it so much haha, maybe he is good for arena too.

[T-Man]

In no particular order

VH - Such bad ass in every way! He remains a great toon, but I still disapprove of the nerf.
Pharaoh - Awesome for all phases of the game.
Navigator - I love his design, and he is a farming machine.

Honorable mention

Aces High - Nice set of skills, and cool design.
Samurai - One of my favorite designs. Was quite good in the arena at one point. Not so much anymore.
Cyborg - Finally dropped for me during the Christmas events. Love the design. Doesn’t seem too useful in the Arena right now, but I haven’t experimented with him much.

[blade685]

For me
1- Navigator (almost for everything)
2- Rainmaker (Arena)
3- Viking (Arena alternative and works with everything)

Anyways, i never had an Aces High and i want it so much haha, maybe he is good for arena too.

Rainmaker??? you want to say VH eddie?
VH have so much better power move and better resist

[Mariner-1212]

I can’t decide which one I like best. But I know which one I don’t like and I think he has the worst design: for me it’s Hallowed Eddie.
Hallowed be thy name is my alltime favorite Maiden Song, but his design doesn’t do the song any pride.
I know that he’s designed after the trooper Beer. His design could need to be reworked. That’s my opinion.

I completely agree. In fact, I don't even think a rework would be worth it. I think he is kept as the Hallowed Beer guy, and they just introduce an Executioner Eddie that does the song more justice.

Top Eddies for utility:
1. Navigator
2. GRE
3. Pharaoh

Top Eddies for looks:
1. Viking
2. Cyborg (don't have)
3. VHE (don't have)

[Ezz]

1) Aces high
2) Navigator
3) Tailgunner

Gunner sweep for me. I like VHE but I use Clair most of the time so no need for his reviving.

[Pablo]

1- Navigator
2- Pharaoh
3- GRE

Would love to consider VHE or AHE but I don´t have, yet...

[Yup]

Navigator (almost everything)
Eternity (BNW Dragon King)
GRE (all around ATK + DEF)

Would LOVE to use Edward the great more but his Special stat is too low (should be doubled to around 500 in my opinion).

[Reeb99]

I don't have any good Eddies after not playing for over a year. Even back then I had horrible luck with pulling any good Eddies. My best are Soldier, Grim Reaper, and Storm. Heh. I did finally pull a Carriage Rider Eddie after I came back, but he doesn't seem to be very good these days.

I will say that borrowing Navigator Eddie is a lot of fun. Comparable to Cyborg before he got nerfed to oblivion long ago. I need to get one of those.

[EnricoPalazzo]

For farming:
Navigator wins this hands down. He can clear AMOLAD almost on his own with the right talismans
Storm (just fun to work with his randomness, good punch with a magic-based team)
Eternity Eddie

For PVE Attack:
Pharao (my general go-to guy, a great supporter for all kinds of teams)
Samurai (just a lot of fun to play, especially with Echo)
Aces High (my counter to Eda teams)

For PVE Defense:
Pharao (see above)
VHE (don't have him but one of the hardest Eddies with the correct support)
Samurai (find a way to fuel his fury often and he's a killer)

(edit for typo)