Which eddie to evolve? Carriage Rider or Soldier?

[aceshigh]

Like i said in title , I have 2 eddies at 4* and i'll evolve. But I can't decide. Which one i should? (Carriage Rider - Soldier) Btw it will be my first 5*

[Dutch]

both are good, soldier is the most versatile but carriage rider is one of the best healers (i have him at 5 and hes a beast)

[Gonzo]

They both are really good. But for your first Eddie I would go with Soldier, he will be the cornerstone of all your future teams.

[Jennie-5128]

Another vote for soldier

[Vaseodin]

A lot of the final bosses are red, so Carriage rider will help you annihilate the campaign. Many swear by Soldier Eddie (he has a very well-balanced set of skills), so you really can't go wrong either way. If you want 2 Eddies that rock, I say Carriage Rider. Many have posted that they beat underworld madness with a 4 star Soldier, but Carriage Rider doesn't really come onto his own until 5 stars. So, if you want 2 strong Eddies, evolve Carriage Rider, as soldier can play with the 5 stars while he is still at 4. If you just want a machine of destruction go with Soldier.

Whatever you do, don't sell your soldier eddie like 1 person-who-shall-remain-unnamed did by mistake (Sorry Jennie!). Make sure you lock all the characters you want to keep. .

[aceshigh]

Thanks for all replies guys. @Vaseodin i liked your post but i finished underworld madness %70 now and like i said i dont have any 5* char . I really dont know which one i should evolve rn :P

[007RAV15-8839]

Flip a coin. If it comes up Soldier and you think best out of three... then you know Carriage is your Eddie.

[slauki]

i love soldier-eddies shield it helps me a lot in the new dungeons, thats why i would level him up

[Jennie-5128]

"Whatever you do, don't sell your soldier eddie like 1 person-who-shall-remain-unnamed did by mistake (Sorry Jennie!). Make sure you lock all the characters you want to keep."

This is excellent advice. Really really excellent advice.

[Gonzo]

Yeah... if you don't know who to rank up, fli a coin, not to make the decision for you, only because when you see the coin in the air you'll realize who YOU want to rank up. `


Grandpa taught me that when I was young. It works every time.

[007RAV15-8839]

Hey grandson, Gonzo, you were paying attention! You could call more.

[aceshigh]

It's getting weird ...

[OpticSugar]

Yeah... if you don't know who to rank up, fli a coin, not to make the decision for you, only because when you see the coin in the air you'll realize who YOU want to rank up. `


Grandpa taught me that when I was young. It works every time.

I do that all the time! Flip a coin, and if you're disappointed with the results, then you know what to do!

I'm in a similar predicament as the OP... I can't decide whether to upgrade my Carriage Rider or my Allied Soldier Magus. I only have enough shards for one. Anyone want to chime in before I flip a coin?

[Dutch]

Carriage rider all the way, allied soldier will soon be obsolete as is mine, never use it any more

[OpticSugar]

"So it shall be written
So it shall be done"

[aur0ra85]

All sage advice.
I have both, I leveled soldier first and am not disappointed. I find carriage rider to be a much more powerful Eddie; however, but he doesn't work as well as soldier Eddie does with miscellaneous ally's.
Carriage rider seems to particularly go well with blue and green characters. Soldier kinda works with any. Same with Eddie's such as samurai who goes best with other red characters for the most part.
It's kinda like deciding which super model you want to take to bed tonight: the blond, or the brunette. I'm a brunette man myself lol.

[aceshigh]

@aur0ra85 wow impressive hahahah . Cheers !

[BillLion]

I do that all the time! Flip a coin, and if you're disappointed with the results, then you know what to do!

I'm in a similar predicament as the OP... I can't decide whether to upgrade my Carriage Rider or my Allied Soldier Magus. I only have enough shards for one. Anyone want to chime in before I flip a coin?

I was in the exact same predicament last night. I went with Carriage Rider!

[BillLion]

But for the record -I still planning on taking my magus allied soldier to 5*s next week.

To the OP, I think you've got some solid input here and can't go wrong either way.

[OpticSugar]

I was in the exact same predicament last night... I went with brunette!