Who to evolve to 5*? SoL Eddie or Holy Smoke Eddie

Hello! After the tuning update Speed Of Light got a good buff as I read in the forums. But Holy Smoke is also a pretty good eddie especially his Rise ability is stronger now. I use primarily The Nomad, and Allied Soldier for my team.

It would be great if you include talisman suggestions too, for exemple should I go all red on HS or 2 Health 4 Strength? Because after the tuning, health became a serious problem. I haven't used SoL at all so I have no idea about him. Any help is appreciated!