already wasted way too much time so i make it short:
attack-lists: not really working. i only have players that are far below me. maybe one every now and then with similary points.
att/def: still not working.
point-system: get 12pts, loose 20pts. i don't have any words for that.
rewards: still not a single reward for playing. the only noteworthy reward is rank 1-3 which is pure p2w.
PvP store: open once a week with only 1 useful thing to buy + one 'legendary' soul per month. why can't i spend my iron coins? don't tell me it would be unfair while the same 2 guys get 6s skillshards per week + ironite
AI: not existent. wrong attack order, useless buffs instead of making the final blow, attacking the wrong toons instead of killing the poor guy with nearly 0 HP...
bugs: well, there are quite some
defense: impossible to build a defense without 2 or 3 key toons. and even then its bad luck if you loose against them with 4*/5* toons. There are quite some nice combos in theory but impossible to use because of ai.
attack: tauntfest, siege and prisoners OPnes are gone, thats nice. but it shows that ai is not capable to defend against a noob-pvp-player like me without.