So I finally pulled enough disposable toons to hit 40k in the pit and wanted to share my results below: I was really hoping for some skill shards but, well that's my luck. But the rewards were still pretty amazing to behold nevertheless. I cashed them all in and got back my Pharaoh Dog King, Assassin NboL, and Gunner Golden Son. My only real loss is Beezy but I had a spare I got from my 5th Eternity soul, only difference is the one I have now isn't sharded, but an acceptable loss as I don't have any uses for him. But I also got a Sentinel Chopper and Magus Trickster so welcome to those new guys. Other notable toons are a dupe SSD, Wickerman, Gunner CotD, and Angel of Pain.
You'd think that cashing in 65 souls total would give me more than just 1 5*, especially with that 5* being someone I JUST gave away...