Hi Sparton
Here are my thoughts... It may happened that some people not having problem with counting that particular achievement ''Master Of Skulls'' - if my memory serves well - that's right? Because they might finish it after you have relesed the achievement system in fact... So the system COULD REGISTER the fact that the new Eddie is obtained that way...
Yet the great majority of players (including myself) have earned three skulls everywhere possible LONG BEFORE the achievement system was set... So it coudn't register this fact, yet it was certain that new Eddie didn't come to us the usual way - through souls - so the system might ignore him, like he never existed...
Why I thought this way? Because after a while of thinking it striked me that the system counts my achievement with clearing LOL dungeons from the very start - like I've never been doing this before, which is obvious nonsense - otherwise I wouldn't have acquired certain stuff to upgrade my toons - I did this hundereds of times already, yet the system not registered that...
Cheers,
W